|(Credit: Screenshot by Lance Whitney/CNET)|
The problem with this is that the Snapchat ghost is very particular. You could even call it a template. For those of you familiar with template matching (what they are asking you to do to verify your humanity), it is one of the easier tasks in computer vision.
This is an incredibly bad way to verify someone is a person because it is such an easy problem for a computer to solve.
After I read this, I spent around ~30 minutes writing up some code in order to make a computer do this. Now there are many ways of solving this problem, HoG probably would have been best or even color thresholding and PCA for blob recognition but it would take more time and I'm lazy (read: efficient). I ended up using OpenCV and going with simple thresholding, SURF keypoints and FLANN matching with a uniqueness test to determine that multiple keypoints in the training image weren't being singularly matched in the testing image.
First, I extract the different images from the slide above, then I threshold them and the ghost template to find objects that are that color. Next, I extract feature points and descriptors from the test image and the template using SURF and match them using FLANN. I only use the "best" matches using a distance metric and then check all the matches for uniqueness to verify one feature in the template isn't matching most of the test features. If the uniqueness is high enough and enough features are found, we call it a ghost.
With very little effort, my code was able to "find the ghost" in the above example with 100% accuracy. I'm not saying it is perfect, far from it. I'm just saying that if it takes someone less than an hour to train a computer to break an example of your human verification system, you are doing something wrong. There are a ton of ways to do this using computer vision, all of them quick and effiective. It's a numbers game with computers and Snapchat's verification system is losing.
Below is an example of the output of the code:
|Found a Ghost!|
And you can find the code on my github here: https://github.com/StevenHickson/FindTheGhost
Note: This just relates to Snapchat's new captcha system. The reason they implemented this was because of the past hacks by people who put way more time and thought into a harder problem. They can be found here:
Graham Smith - https://twitter.com/neuegram - http://neuebits.com/
Adam Caudill - http://adamcaudill.com/2012/12/31/revisiting-snapchat-api-and-security/
Gibson Security - http://gibsonsec.org/